Types of Communication

Types Of Communication That Work in Every Situation

Home About Us Blog Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms of Use

The Right of the Deaf Child to Grow Up Bilingual

September 8th, 2009 by admin

2 The Right of the Deaf Child to Grow Up BilingualThis video talks about why it is not a good idea to have oral-approach only.

Transcript:

Hi! I would like to share about the article written by Francois Grosjean who provided his perspective by researching Deaf children. The article mentioned that ASL should be the primary language of a Deaf child. Despite the use of various technological aids ( i.e. cochlear implants), sign language is mandatory period. Why? I will explain the reasons for you to think about it.

When hearing babies are born, they normally acquire language in the very first years of life that their parents communicate with them and that babies receive information by listening to surrounding sound environment such as T.V., radio, people having conversations, etc. Even some parents sign with their hearing babies making it more accessible. “Language in turn is an important means of establishing and solidifying social and personal ties between the child and his/her parents. What is true of the hearing child must also become true of the Deaf child.”

It is crucial for Deaf children to see a visual, 100 percent accessible, natural signed language that they are able to completely comprehend the information as they grow up.

But is this really happening for all Deaf children? Unfortunately, no. Why? Organizations like AG Bell, AVT (Auditory Verbal Therapy), etc. think it is not necessary to include ASL but focus on listening and speaking ONLY. That only approach HURTS! I will explain to you why.

First of all, we don’t know for sure if a Deaf baby will grasp information completely through auditory. All cochlear implant users don’t pick up the information in the same way. We know that some hearing aid users have developed strong listening skills and some of them don’t at all in spite of having the same decibel loss. Too often, people ume by exposing one language (oral) would do just fine until the moment they realize that this approach did not work. So what happens to that child? “He or she falls BEHIND in his/her development, be it linguistic, cognitive, social, or personal.” It becomes TOO LATE!

This issue is disturbing to DBC that this oral only approach is GAMBLING the Deaf child’s life away from academic development, social development, healthy emotional development, etc. We need to advocate more strongly on having both languages, ASL and English, for all Deaf children.

The responsibility, the duty and the goal of DBC are to make sure that ALL Deaf babies from the start have access to natural sign language that is acquired naturally as much as possible where two-way communication takes place. For a Deaf child to bridge to English (spoken English and/or written English), the most important part for academic success and future professional achievements is to master written English. Once a Deaf child has the ability to write well, he/she can do anything!

By using one language (oral) approach and excluding ASL with those who use listening istive devices, is it a right way? No! We know that obviously oralism involves RISK! BET! GAMBLE!

Having the ability to develop cognitive/personal skills will be minimized when using oral only approach. Why limit the Deaf child’s ability? He or she would have developed much more advanced in these areas (linguistic, cognitive, social and personal). Oral approach with most Deaf children is not perceived as communicating in a two-way street in a natural way. Research states that for a Deaf child to use oral only approach impedes communication and that the daunting effort to develop speech skills is consumed rather than focusing on developing cognitive skills. When using ASL, “it allows the young Deaf child and his/her parents to communicate early, and fully, on the condition that they acquire it quickly.” ASL play an important role in the Deaf child’s cognitive and social development and it will help him/her acquire knowledge about the world. They can express about anything that is much easier and clearer for them to communicate.

Hearing parents can learn signs and they need to get more support. What DBC wants to see happening out there is the establishment of ASL Therapy Centers. We don’t even have one here in America but we always have numerous speech therapy centers even hotline phone numbers where immediate attention can be given. More fund is needed to establish such centers where support to facilitate hearing parents’ signing skills will be much more possible in the future.

In the meantime, DBC has been sharing an important message that every Deaf baby has the right to sign. Why is this so important? There are numerous benefits and opportunities using ASL when a Deaf child grows up. In this case, opportunities are more of GUARANTEES.

BILINGUAL (ASL/ENGLISH) GUARANTEES A DEAF CHILD’S FUTURE!

Duration : 0:5:32


 The Right of the Deaf Child to Grow Up Bilingual
admin
View all posts by admin
s website

Visual literacy

Posted in Uncategorized types of communication posts | 7 Comments »

7 Responses

  1. Starwar1970 Says:

    I agree with lady. …
    I agree with lady. I was little girl and took classes for oral all day and stilled not understand what teacher says. Teacher always scold me a lot for not understand. I was more afraid of teachers because of oral.
    Until age 12 years old. Fianl! I was very glad to learn sign langage because help me more understand than oral. Oral is really hurt deaf people.

  2. megbenj Says:

    Absolutely agree. I …
    Absolutely agree. I work in a collaborative school program with deaf/hh kids (ages 3-8) and ASL/Pidgin Sign Language is the main mode of communication for the teachers, speech therapists, istants etc etc…they can mainstream with interpreter if applicable…but totally agree, MUST give child opportunity to learn language as soon as possible just like hearing child!

  3. DeafBilingual Says:

    The speaker is …
    The speaker is advocating ASL to be included other than spoken English. The speaker strongly support both, ASL and spoken English (if applicable) /written English, not Signed English, S.E.E. or any sort of Manually Coded English since these are not true languages. Hope this helps to clarify the misconception that you are having based on your comments.

  4. DeafBilingual Says:

    The DBC agrees with …
    The DBC agrees with you that parents play a crucial role in enhancing their child’s success in school. However, it bothers us that they are not being completely informed about the benefits of bilingual education that they should be helping their Deaf child to develop a strong language base, using ASL, that is, to learn English more effectively.

  5. DeafBilingual Says:

    There is a …
    There is a misinterpretation here. The speaker never said that TC is better so that is where you getting confused with this idea. Actually, she is not talking about TC. You can see it clearly that nowhere in the video and the transcript that this speaker advocates for TC. Do you really know what TC means?

  6. Dennis31190 Says:

    that’s a really …
    that’s a really interesting clip. i’m deaf and i didn’t learn how to sign ’til i was about nine or ten. sooo it’s really interesting to hear your perspective on that topic. it depends on the parents, the parents have to be involved with the deaf’s child life and it might will help. my mom was quite involved with my life, so it helped alot. =]

  7. OregonBLB Says:

    “BILINGUAL (ASL/ …
    “BILINGUAL (ASL/ENGLISH) GUARANTEES A DEAF CHILD’S FUTURE!”

    A no-risk guarantee? Total communication is ALWAYS better? That is simply not true. You can’t make that kind of guarantee, and it is irresponsible to say that you can. I have seen transfers into an oral-only program who did far better, academically and emotionally, than they had in the total communication program available to them.

    Help with risk essment, fine. Don’t imply that there is an option without risk.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Mike Noone- creator of the toughest NLP training in the world



STOP Kidding yourself…

If You knew how to make the changes you want you would have done it by now...

Getting what you want is a science and if you're here now it's probably because you're not getting it

Enter your name and PRIMARY email address to access the influence and popularity getting tactics you crave.

Get tips and valuable information on how to start getting your own way Today.
* Get Your Tough Love Here *
* indicates required